Category Archives: education

Educational innovation versus educational quality

Wombat of the Copier wrote: “Then I had to see what was on the discs and files I’d gotten from publishers with textbooks and proposed textbooks. It’s all like this. It’s all trash…The seven other discs I pulled out of my trunk from texts I reviewed for use, but didn’t use, were garbage…They are ENCOURAGING professors to suck. Is it a conspiracy? If they make enough of us worthless, are they going to take over the world with online education? WTF?” Wasn’t it Robert Heinlein who said, “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity”? Ever since at least the 1920s, with John Dewey, the pattern has been for some education professional to introduce with breathless enthusiasm a new concept they claim is going to Read more

Posted in American education, bad ideas, despair, education, education reform, science, wishful thinking | Leave a comment

Friday thirsty: Raising the bar

Chris Dawson, the education blogger over at ZDNet, has a post up today about not dumbing things down. It seems he was asked to read a book, The Bee Tree, and prepare a presentation on it for his son’s third-grade class. So he dug into his graduate-school calculus: Bees, as it turns out, create a completely optimal space for their honey, raising their young, and storing food. The hexagonal shape of honeycomb cells actually maximizes interior volume while minimizing surface area. Since bees must eat about 8 times the volume of honey for a given volume of wax that they need to create their hives, wax is a precious commodity, so optimization is key. Obviously I wouldn’t expect the third-graders to be able to handle calculus-based optimization problems (in fact, the so-called Read more

Posted in challenge, education, introvert.prof, learning, thirsty | Leave a comment